|
When an Apple
Loves a Worm
By BEN BRANTLEY
THE
look of love beams like a laser from Brian Bedford's
eyes in the handsome, absorbing new production
of Molière's "Tartuffe" that
opened last night at the American Airlines Theater.
It's that glazed, honeyed gaze found among men
who, having surprised themselves by falling
in love in their autumn years, have also fallen
into a dream. Mr. Bedford's character, a bourgeois
gentilhomme named Orgon, looks so happily enchanted
that it seems almost a shame that he has to
be awakened.
Mind you, the creature who has
so captivated Orgon is not your usual midlife-crisis-making
bosomy blonde, but a bony brunette with stringy
hair and a pasty complexion. This gold digger
— a fellow known as Tartuffe, by the way
— is portrayed with ghoulishly zestful
appetite by Henry Goodman. |
 |
And while there have perhaps been
odder couples in the history of Broadway, the most fascinatingly
perverse sparks set off this season have to be those
generated between Mr. Bedford and Mr. Goodman.
Before we proceed, let it be recorded
that in the early 21st century Henry Goodman did indeed
have the chance to play a flamboyant, fast-talking
con man on Broadway and that he did so with flair,
inventiveness and comic assurance. Mr. Goodman, you
may recall, became the subject of last season's most
dramatic theatrical imbroglio when he was dismissed
from the comic role of another flamboyant con man.
The part was Max Bialystock, created
for the musical "The Producers" by Nathan
Lane, an audience-hijacking performer whose shoes
no one should ever have to step into. But that was
the task assigned to Mr. Goodman, a celebrated actor
of the London stage, who jumped into the role and
was summarily yanked from it after four weeks, before
critics had a chance to review him.
Having now seen Mr. Goodman's charismatic,
eely Tartuffe, who brings to mind John Barrymore being
sinister in a silent movie, I have to say that I feel
cheated by having missed his Max. But that, as they
say, is another oil slick under the bridge. And it
is New York's good fortune now to have Mr. Goodman
strutting his stuff in high, nasty style in the title
role of Molière's classic play about religious
charlatanism.
Not that Mr. Goodman entirely owns
this "Tartuffe," which has been mounted
with 17th-century savoir-faire by Joe Dowling, the
artistic director of the Guthrie Theater in Minneapolis,
and the set designer John Lee Beatty. If Molière's
spirited comic fable has more psychological credibility
than usual in this production from the Roundabout
Theater — which also features J. Smith-Cameron
and Kathryn Meisle — it owes even more to Mr.
Bedford's plump pigeon than it does to Mr. Goodman's
sharp-beaked bird of prey.
The problem with most interpretations
of "Tartuffe" lies in their failure to convince
the audience that a blatant mountebank like the title
character — a man of pious poses, Jesuitical
speech and conspicuous lust — could deceive
anyone, even such a fatuous fellow as Orgon, who has
brought this serpent into the bosom of his family
as a spiritual guide. After all, Tartuffe isn't loath
to show his true, darker colors to almost everyone
else in Orgon's household. Just how gullible can a
gull be?
Still, anyone who has watched a man
of, say, some 50 or 60 years — with his children
grown and the grave in his foreseeable future —
suddenly start clutching at signs of new life will
recognize Mr. Bedford's Orgon. Some men buy red sports
cars; some acquire new wives with silicone breasts.
This Orgon brings the same desperately hopeful spirit,
tinged with eroticism, to his pursuit of religious
enlightenment.
 |
The truly wondrous
Mr. Bedford, who delivered another dazzling
profile in fatuity in the Roundabout's "London
Assurance" in 1997, turns Orgon into a
beatific study in denial. Rather than the usual
stuffy, tyrannical paterfamilias of most productions
of "Tartuffe," Mr. Bedford's Orgon
has a malleable sweetness. (When you see him
backing away from his aged mother, played with
dragonlike fierceness by Rosaleen Linehan, you
get a glimpse of what shaped him.)
It makes sense that this fellow,
probably troubled by new thoughts of mortality
and regrets about his past, would fall into
the crafty hands of a poseur promising redemption.
And Mr. Goodman, while guilty of a few instances
of forced comic shtick, cannily plays Tartuffe
as a Svengali who has by now so thoroughly hypnotized
his victim that he knows exactly how much he
can get away with.
|
In the one big scene the men share
in the play's first half, there's an unsettling element
of sexual teasing in Tartuffe's manipulation of the
besotted Orgon. Mr. Goodman, who finds a criminal coldness
and working-class resentment beneath his character's
hair shirt, delivers a Tartuffe who knows all too well
that physical and spiritual longings are not mutually
exclusive.
At such moments, Orgon and Tartuffe
might indeed have stepped straight from those incisive
paintings of politicians and men of wealth by LeBrun,
portraits that invariably inspire speculations on
the scheming personalities of their subjects. This
would appear to have been Mr. Dowling's overall intention
with this "Tartuffe," which is set firmly
in the mid-17th century and has been given ravishingly
detailed physical life.
Mr. Beatty, who created the knockout
Deco-style sets for the current Lincoln Center production
of "Dinner at Eight," does similarly impressive
duty here, rendering Orgon's Paris town house as a
wood-paneled, ormolu-accented temple to haute bourgeois
affluence, perfectly matched by Brian MacDevitt's
painterly lighting and Jane Greenwood's frilled costumes.
Not everyone inhabits this environment
— or Richard Wilbur's standard rhymed translation
— with the same ease that Mr. Bedford does.
There are those inevitable, numbing moments when the
moralizing, singsong quality of recited poetry descends.
But it's an agreeable supporting cast, and everyone
has his or her moment to shine. It's a pleasure to
see the throaty Ms. Smith-Cameron (of "As Bees
in Honey Drown") back on stage, bringing genuine
warmth to the somewhat tedious role of Dorine, the
plucky, truth-speaking maid.
As Orgon's delectable wife, Ms. Meisle,
who brings to mind the vulpine slyness of the young
Annette Bening, does wonderfully by the famous seduction
scene in which Tartuffe is entrapped. And Jeffrey
Carlson, recently seen as the troubled son in "The
Goat," manages to find fresh ways of communicating
adolescent angst through Baroque frippery as the suitor
of Orgon's daughter, Mariane (the charming Bryce Dallas
Howard).
But it's Mr. Goodman and Mr. Bedford
who provide the surprises of emotional shading that
make this more than just another attractively upholstered
revival. Mr. Bedford, in particular, discovers an
almost tragic pathos in this oft-revisited comedy.
When Orgon is finally delivered from
evil (in a deus ex machina that is presented with
a perfect balance of irony and wonder here), he doesn't
look entirely happy. In fact, the last expression
seen on Mr. Bedford's face is that of a man who has
just been banished from paradise and can't figure
out why.
TARTUFFE
By Molière; translation by Richard Wilbur;
directed by Joe Dowling; sets by John Lee Beatty;
costumes by Jane Greenwood; lighting by Brian MacDevitt;
original music and sound by Mark Bennett; dialect
coach, Elizabeth Smith; production stage manager,
Jane Pole; hair and wig design by Paul Huntley; associate
artistic director, Scott Ellis; technical supervisor,
Steve Beers; general manager, Sydney Davolos; director
of marketing, David B. Steffen. Presented by the Roundabout
Theater Company, Todd Haimes, artistic director; Ellen
Richard, managing director; Julia C. Levy, executive
director, external affairs. At the American Airlines
Theater, 227 West 42nd Street, Manhattan.
WITH: Brian Bedford
(Orgon), Henry Goodman (Tartuffe), J. Smith-Cameron
(Dorine), Rosaleen Linehan (Mme. Pernelle), Kathryn
Meisle (Elmire), T. R. Knight (Damis), Bryce Dallas
Howard (Mariane), John Bedford Lloyd (Cléante),
Jeffrey Carlson (Valère) and Philip Goodwin
(M. Loyal).
Fuente:
The New York Times
Enero 2003
TeatroenMiami.com
|